Our story
A home away from home, on the water
Heartland Stays began as a family dream — to share the magic of Florida's Gulf Coast with guests who crave something more personal than a hotel.
How it all started
In 2018, the Johnson family purchased a modest beachfront property in Arcadia, Florida with one goal: create the kind of retreat they always wished existed. Not a cookie-cutter rental, but a true villa — thoughtfully designed, impeccably maintained, and filled with the warmth of a private home.
Over two years of renovation, they transformed the property into what guests now call 'the most beautiful place we've ever stayed.' Every detail — from the infinity pool overlooking the Gulf to the hand-selected local artwork — was chosen with care.
Today, Heartland Stays hosts guests from around the world who return year after year. We manage every booking personally, so you'll always reach a real person who knows the property inside and out.
Personal service
Every guest gets our direct number. We're here before, during, and after your stay.
Immaculate care
The villa is professionally cleaned and inspected before every arrival — no exceptions.
Local knowledge
We've lived here for years. Our area guide is the real deal, not a generic tourist list.
Explore the area
Arcadia sits on Florida's southwest Gulf Coast — close enough to everything, far enough from the crowds.
Manasota Key Beach
A quiet, undeveloped barrier island beach with crystal-clear water and almost no crowds.
Englewood Beach
Wider stretch of Gulf beach with beach bars, volleyball, and stunning sunsets.
The Waverly
Upscale waterfront dining with fresh Gulf seafood and an award-winning wine list.
Farlow's on the Water
Local favorite for casual waterfront lunches — the grouper sandwich is legendary.
Stump Pass Beach State Park
Kayaking, shelling, and nature trails through pristine Florida coastal habitat.
Myakka River State Park
Florida's largest state park — airboat tours, alligators, and old-Florida wilderness.
Getting here
Arcadia, FL 34266
From the North
From I-75 North: Take Exit 191 toward Englewood/Venice. Head west on River Road for 14 miles, then south on Manasota Beach Road. The villa entrance is on the right.
From the South
From I-75 South: Take Exit 170 toward Port Charlotte. Head west on US-17 for 8 miles, then north on Manasota Beach Road. The villa entrance is on the left.
Nearest airports
Nearest airports: Sarasota-Bradenton (SRQ) — 45 min. Fort Myers (RSW) — 55 min. Tampa (TPA) — 90 min.
Parking
The villa includes a private 3-car garage plus additional driveway parking. Street parking is also available.
Ready to experience it for yourself?
Book your stay